November 2, 2026
Ms. Jennifer Sirangelo
President and Chief Executive Officer
Points of Light
600 Means Street NW, Suite 210
Atlanta, Georgia 30318
Re: The 2026 George H.W. Bush Points of Light Award
Dear Ms. Sirangelo:
We write to you as bereaved families who lost our children to the harms of social media, many of us on Snapchat itself.
On October 13, Points of Light presented Evan Spiegel, the co-founder and chief executive officer of Snap Inc., with the George H.W. Bush Points of Light Award, the highest honor your organization bestows. Your own materials say this award recognizes the traits of our forty-first president: integrity, empathy, respect, optimism, and conviction in the face of opposition. Mr. Spiegel’s career does not remotely reflect these traits.
For many of us, the threat that took our children was Snapchat, a product harming millions of America’s children. Some of our children were lost to a counterfeit pill poisoned with fentanyl, sold by a dealer who found them on Snapchat; some to suicide after sextortion facilitated through Snapchat’s disappearing messages; some to suicide after relentless cyberbullying waged over those same vanishing messages. The rest of us lost our children on different social media platforms, often to features that Snapchat pioneered and its competitors copied.
Some of our children’s names may already be familiar to you. Sammy Chapman was sixteen when a drug dealer connected with him on Snapchat and delivered the counterfeit, fentanyl-laced pills that killed him. Nate Bronstein was fifteen when he took his life after relentless cyberbullying carried out over text threads and Snapchat, including a Snapchat message telling him to go kill himself; his parents have spent every day since building a national movement against bullying. Tragically, just nineteen days before his seventeenth birthday, Daniel Puerta died from illicit fentanyl poisoning after unknowingly taking a counterfeit prescription pill purchased through Snapchat. He had no idea the pill contained a lethal amount of illicitly manufactured fentanyl. Alexander Neville was fourteen when a dealer he connected with on Snapchat sold him what he believed was oxycodone. It was fentanyl, and he never woke up; his mother, Amy, is the lead plaintiff in the families’ case against Snap. These are but four of thousands of such stories.
Points of Light does real good in this country; your expertise is volunteering and civic life. It is not the social media industry, nor social media safety. No one should have expected your award committee to understand Mr. Spiegel’s history, in which we have tragically become reluctant experts. Now we share some of that information with you, and we respectfully ask that you rescind this honor from someone who does not meet its stated criteria.
Snapchat was conceived in 2011 by three fraternity brothers at Stanford around a single founding premise: messages that disappear. Early press coverage bluntly described the app as built for sexting. Mr. Spiegel and his partner then forced out the fraternity brother who conceived the disappearing-message idea and denied his role for years, acknowledging it only after Mr. Spiegel’s own messages and admissions surfaced in court filings; Snap paid him $157.5 million to settle, a figure disclosed in its IPO papers. And when emails from Mr. Spiegel’s fraternity years became public in 2014, messages joking about getting sorority women drunk, he did not dispute writing them. He said he was mortified and that they did not reflect who he had become. President Bush’s life was defined by humility, loyalty, and service. We leave it to you to judge whether this founding story honors his name.
Fifteen years later, that same disappearing-evidence design is what the New Mexico Attorney General and the families suing Snap identify as the feature that draws drug dealers and predators to the platform. In September 2024, New Mexico’s Attorney General sued Snap after an undercover investigation, and the unredacted complaint quotes Snap’s own internal communications: employees discussing roughly 10,000 user reports of sextortion every month, warnings that reports of child grooming were falling through the cracks, and former trust and safety employees stating they faced pushback on in-app safety mechanisms because Mr. Spiegel prioritized design. A New Mexico court denied Snap’s motion to dismiss, and the case is in discovery.
New Mexico is not alone. Eight states have now sued Snap. Nevada sued first, calling Snapchat an addiction machine. Florida, the state Governor Jeb Bush led for eight years, sued in April 2025 for knowingly giving accounts to children under fourteen and deceiving their parents about the app’s dangers. Utah, Kansas, Texas, Arkansas, and Pennsylvania have followed with suits over addictive design, the facilitation of drug sales and sextortion, and the misuse of children’s data; Pennsylvania’s Attorney General, filing this August, said his investigators found “a mountain of evidence” that Snap knows how addictive its platform is. New York City has sued as well. And when the bipartisan coalition of more than fifty attorneys general announced its settlement of up to seventeen billion dollars with Meta this August, the coalition publicly named Snapchat as a company facing state enforcement actions and investigations. Its co-lead said Snap is among its next targets.
And then there are the families. More than sixty, some of us among them, are suing Snap in Los Angeles Superior Court over the fentanyl poisoning deaths of their children. Snap tried twice to have that case thrown out, at the trial court and at the California Court of Appeal, and lost both times; it now faces discovery and depositions under oath. Beyond them, Snap is a defendant in the largest coordinated child safety litigation in American history, thousands of federal and state cases alleging that Snapchat was deliberately designed to addict children.
Congress has pressed Mr. Spiegel for years. In September 2022, a bipartisan group of senators wrote to him and three other chief executives demanding answers about fentanyl-laced counterfeit pills sold to teenagers on their social media platforms, and days later members of the House Energy and Commerce Committee sent Mr. Spiegel their own letter about drug dealers using Snapchat to reach children. In February 2025, witnesses before the Senate Judiciary Committee testified that when Snap executives met with bereaved parents in 2021, the executives began by claiming not to know that children buy drugs on Snapchat. Snap’s own records tell a different story: in 2019, after a news article described Snapchat’s popularity with drug dealers, Snap’s communications director wrote internally that drug dealing on the app had “increased significantly,” and later that year Snap’s own meeting notes recognized that “some bad actors prefer to transact on Snapchat given the ephemerality of communications on our platform.”
Then, in April 2025, the Chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee wrote to Mr. Spiegel by name, citing a case in which a dealer kept selling drugs to middle and high school students on Snapchat for months after law enforcement obtained a search warrant, until a sixteen-year-old boy died. The Chairman wrote that such instances raise concerns about the sincerity of Snap’s efforts to end fentanyl sales on its platform.
And the scrutiny is not only civil. In January 2023, Bloomberg reported that the FBI and the Justice Department were examining Snapchat’s role in the spread and sale of fentanyl-laced pills, with federal investigators interviewing bereaved parents and reviewing Snapchat records obtained by subpoena. In 2025, CBS News reported that Justice Department attorneys and the FBI were focused on overdose deaths in which subpoenas showed the fatal sales were arranged on Snapchat. And in January 2025, the Federal Trade Commission, stating that its investigation found “reason to believe Snap is violating or is about to violate the law,” referred a complaint against the company to the Justice Department over the risks its My AI feature poses to young users. Snap disclosed that referral in its own filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission.
And this year, when Snap finally faced the prospect of a jury, it did not defend its conduct. It settled. In January 2026, Snap settled with the first bellwether plaintiff days before the first social media addiction trial in American history began in Los Angeles. The companies that stayed, Meta and Google, were found negligent by that jury in March for the harm done to a young user’s mental health. Snap settled with the next bellwether plaintiff in July, and settled a Kentucky school district’s claims in May, each time before Mr. Spiegel could be examined in open court. A company does not keep paying to avoid trials about dead and injured children because it is confident the evidence vindicates it.
We have stood in front of Mr. Spiegel before. In January 2024, at a Senate hearing, Senator Laphonza Butler asked him to address the parents in the room whose children had died from drugs purchased on Snapchat. We were among them, holding photographs of our children. “I’m so sorry that we have not been able to prevent these tragedies,” he said, and then he described Snap’s efforts. Senator Butler’s reply was that none of those efforts were keeping kids from getting drugs on his platform, and parents who heard the apology said that day that it meant nothing. We have watched the apologies, the awareness partnerships, and the safety announcements for five years while the funerals continued. What we have not seen are the design changes that would actually protect children, changes Snap’s own employees proposed and, according to the New Mexico complaint, were pushed back on from the top.
Let us be clear about what Snapchat is, because this award forces the question. Quite simply, Snapchat is not a necessary product for society, certainly not for children. No one has ever explained what a disappearing-message service gives a child that ordinary messaging does not, because the honest answer is the very problem: its defining feature is the destruction of evidence, and the people who benefit most from destroyed evidence are drug dealers, predators, fraudsters, and cyberbullies.
And Mr. Spiegel always had choices that would have protected children. Snap could have meaningfully verified its users’ ages; according to Florida’s complaint, it knowingly provides accounts to children under fourteen today. It could have opened Snapchat to the third-party safety software parents already use on other social media platforms; no law prevents that, and none is required. It could have removed particularly dangerous features, including Quick Add, which drug and human traffickers, among others, have used to quickly connect to child targets. And if Snapchat cannot be made safe for children, Snap could stop offering it to children. It has done none of these things, and the only explanation that fits the record is the simple one: each of those choices costs engagement, and engagement is revenue. That is not integrity, and it is not conviction. It is an expedient business decision, made again and again, and children, many of them ours, paid for that profit with their lives.
Mr. Spiegel’s philanthropy may have benefited real people. But a humanitarian award should measure the totality of one’s record, especially for someone with immense power and resources. Mr. Spiegel’s business impacts millions of American children every day, with a product that courts, attorneys general, United States senators, and Snap’s own employees have described as dangerous to them. Charitable giving alongside that record is not humanitarianism; it is reputation management of the most cynical kind.
And the message of this award reaches far beyond Snap. For those of us who lost children on other social media platforms, it tells every executive in the industry that a company can be sued by eight states, settle case after case on the eve of trial, and still be celebrated as a humanitarian. That is the lesson the industry will learn from this award unless you correct it.
We know what we are asking. Publicly rescinding an award is painful for any nonprofit that depends on the goodwill of philanthropists to fund genuinely good work. But look again at what this award claims to honor. Integrity is correcting a mistake once you see it. Empathy is standing with grieving families rather than with the corporation that profited from their losses. Conviction in the face of opposition is doing the right thing even when the honoree is a billionaire. Rescinding this award would not diminish it. It would be the most faithful expression of its criteria in the award’s history.
If further conversation would help you or your board as you consider this, we would welcome it.
We await your response.
Sincerely,
The undersigned families
(Signatories listed below)
cc: Mr. Neil Bush, Chair, Board of Directors, Points of Light